Saturday, August 3, 2013

Lettermen Lost

Okay, before we even start camp and begin worrying about positions and players and drawing comparisons to last year’s team, which is both unfair and unproductive as there is nothing anyone can do about it, let’s take a last look and then close the book one who we do not have and move on.

Braxton Cave – Center

Story: A multiple year starter at a position that is pivotal on the O-line.  Braxton was experienced and strong while providing leadership for the offense as a whole.  Anytime you lose an effective center there could be issues, since EVERY play starts in his hands.  However, it looks like Nick Martin is going to develop nicely in the center position and provide strength in the middle for years to come.

Loss / Outlook: Big loss of experience and leadership, but Martin will make it less noticeable.

Jordan Cowart – Long Snapper

Story:  Jordan appeared in 44 games over four years with the Irish making him a player who took a lot of special team’s game experience with him.  Sophomore Long Snapper Scott Daily takes over with a year of practice under his belt but no game experience.

Loss / Outlook: Although the long snapper position sees very limited field time, it is a very important position.  A loss of a four year player who had a strong hold on the position being replaced with an athlete with no game experience could be a huge loss.  Brian Kelly is ready to reload with redshirt freshman Scott Daly on scholarship who was named high school long snapper of the year in 2011.

Tyler Eifert – Tight End

Story:  Even with only playing three years, Eifert is arguably one of the best tight end in Notre Dame history.  Taking over for another great Irish tight end in NFL Pro Bowl MVP Kyle Rudolph, Efiert had big shoes to fill and did so in outstanding fashion.  The tight end has become an important part of Kelly’s offense due to Eifert showing flexibility in splitting out wide.  There are a number of successors to the thrown at “Tight End U” but none appearing to be as good as Eifert.

Loss / Outlook:  With Tyler rewriting the Irish record books for the tight end position, his departure is a very big hit to the offensive game plan for the Irish.  All is not lost the list of replacements is long with potential and possibilities from Troy Niklas who is otherwise referred to as Hercules and has two years of game experience (one on defense and one on offense), to incoming freshman Mike Heuerman along with converted basketball player Joey Brooks and waiting for what we had hoped for in tight ends Alex Welch and Ben Koyack.

Mike Golic - Offensive Guard

Story:  Two years ago, looking forward this loss would be inconsequential at best, but Mike Golic worked his way onto the O-line contributing where he was needed.  Coming into South Bend as a legacy with a huge family name at Notre Dame, Golic did not play his freshman year and saw very limited time during his sophomore campaign.  As a junior, he appeared in 12 games in a reserved role, enough to prove he should be given a fifth year where he started all 13 games.  Although he was a bit inconsistent, he did was asked of him and contributed to the offense.

Loss / Outlook: The Irish are pretty solid in potential on the O-line and should recover well but losing a fifth year leader on the line is not an easy replacement. 

Jake Golic – Tight End

Story:  Another Golic legacy, Jake played in a handful of games as a reserve and never really contributed on the field.  With a year of eligibility left and no chance of being given a fifth year in South Bend, Jake is moving onto the University of Cincinnati.

Loss / Outlook:  As a reserve tight end, he was barely a blip on the radar and with a stable full of tight ends with potential, the Irish will have plenty of depth at the position.

John Goodman – Wide Receiver

Story:  A fifth year player last season, John never lived up to expectations based on his athleticism but he did prove to be a leader.  Goodman did contribute to the offense in his final year at a higher level and made some great plays which he will be remembered for, but he will not be remembered for his receiving statistics.

Loss / Outlook:  He will be missed more as a leader on the team than on the field of play.  Much like the tight end position, Notre Dame seems to have a healthy stable of receivers to offer depth if not quality.

Kapron Lewis-Moore – Defensive End

Story:  Like a fine wine, Kap seemed to get better with time, appearing in 45 games while starting 42 of them.  After an injury in 2011, Lewis-Moore established himself as a leader of the team on and off the field.  Kapron was the elder statesman of a young defensive line that dominated in 2012.

Loss / Outlook:  From a leadership and experience standpoint this is a sizable loss, but with names like Tuitt, Day, Jones, Springmann, and Hounshell the future is promising at this position.

Dan McCarthy – Safety

Story:  After not playing his freshman year, Dan continued to grow and contribute primarily on special teams as his career progressed.  Dan brought experience and veteran leadership to the defensive backfield in 2012 which it lacked.

Loss / Outlook:  The Irish secondary continues to grow and mature.  McCarthy’s leadership will be missed, but overall performance in the defensive backfield will be better in 2013.

Zeke Motta – Safety

Story:  An athlete who played in 51 games while starting 29 during his Irish career including playing in every game as a freshman (mostly on special teams), Zeke fit the roll of a game tried veteran for the defense in 2012.  A solid safety lending leadership to a youthful secondary bolstered their confidence and maturity.

Loss / Outlook:  The Irish secondary will miss his leadership and experience in 2013.  There is, however, reason to be optimistic with both experience and talent returning to the safety position for the Irish in 2013.

Theo Riddick – Running Back

Story:  This running back, I mean wide receiver, I mean running back, played wherever and whenever he was needed proving he was a team player first and foremost and in the process became a true offensive weapon.  His versatility, coupled with speed and toughness, made him the number one back (sorry Cierre).

Loss / Outlook:  The loss of Cierre Wood makes the absence of Riddick that much more devastating.  The Irish head into the 2013 campaign with a lot of question marks at running back.  Make no mistake, there is a ton of potential at running back, but the departure of Riddick leaves the Irish short in the game experience department.

Chris Salvi – Safety

Story:  After transferring from Butler after one year, Salvi became a fan favorite playing primarily on special teams in 35 games over three years.

Loss / Outlook:  The Irish will survive at safety and special teams next season without Salvi.  However his “pop” will be missed on special teams.

Matt Tansey – Offensive Lineman

Story:  Practice squad player out of New Jersey who has been a walk on since 2012 moving on to become a Navy pilot.

Loss / Outlook: Another man of character moving through South Bend and the Navy gains in the process.

Manti Te’o – Linebacker

Story:  I remember watching the first game Te’o played for the Irish as a freshman and thinking “this kid is going to be something special.” Little did I know how true that would be.  Manti will go down as one of the best the Irish have ever had, period.  We could go on and on about his greatness but his accomplishments are already well chronicled.

Loss / Outlook:  There is no replacing the talents of Manti Te’o.  On the bright side, the future looks good for Notre Dame’s inside linebacker corps with fifth year seniors Carlo Calabrese and Dan Fox as well as Jarrett Grace and Kendall Moore.

Robby Toma – Wide Receiver

Story:  Many people felt Roma was an add-on with Manti Te’o from Punahou High School in Hawaii.  However, Robby grew into an integral part of the Irish offense, redefining the slot position.    Robby had sure hands, was tough as nails and had the courage to go over the middle without fear and could add a flash to offense if needed. 

Loss / Outlook:  Robby was a veteran leader on the team and will be missed on the field and in the locker room.  Kelly and his staff have done a good job getting athletes who can be versatile who need to show their talents on the field as Toma did.

Ben Turk – Punter

Story:  Turk became the starting punter six games into his freshman season and never looked back.  Ben was a solid punter until his senior year where he was exceptional.

Loss / Outlook:  Although most people won’t agree, this could be one of Notre Dame’s biggest losses.  Losing a quality punter can hurt any team’s field positioning and ability to control the opposing offense.  Junior kick off specialist Kyle Brindza will most likely add punting duties to his portfolio.

Cierre Wood – Running Back

Story:  Wood played in 37 games over three seasons averaging 5.4 yards per carry while racking up nearly 2,500 yards.  With a year of eligibility remaining, Cierre left the Irish to test the waters in the NFL (where he went undrafted and signed as a free agent with the Houston Texans), as opposed to being the featured back on a team that just went 12-1 and played for the National Championship.  Sorry for my bitterness, but I believe he could have had 1,000+ yards in 2013.

Loss / Outlook:  Wood’s departure leaves the Irish a little cloudy as to having a clear cut premier back.  Notre Dame is as deep in potential as it is shallow with game experience at the running back position.

Davonte Neal – Wide Receiver

Story:  After a rocky recruitment and announcement, Neal came to South Bend where he maintained the Irish’s shaky punt return statistics.  After the season he transferred to Arizona.

Loss / Outlook: Neal looked like an supernatural talent from his high school highlight films and was supposed to spark Notre Dame’s punt return game last fall, but it did not happen.  This transfer came with little surprise and gives Brian Kelly another scholarship spot to use on someone who wants to be there.

Everett Golson – Quarterback

Story:  Golson is academically ineligible for the season.  Stupid is as stupid does.  I give it a 50/50 chance of him returning to South Bend. 

Loss / Outlook:  Losing a starting quarterback who took you thorough and undefeated season, no matter how much he still needed to grow, is still a BIG loss.  On the bright side, our back up moving into the starting role has played in 33 games and has started 18, which is not so bad.  The down side is Zaire will have to see the field this year and burn a year of eligibility to prepare for the possibility of starting next year.

Jamoris Slaughter – Safety

Story:  Slaughter was denied a sixth year of eligibility by the NCAA after he tore his Achilles tendon during the third game of the 2012 season.  Jamoris was selected in the sixth round of the NFL draft by the Cleveland Browns. 

Loss / Outlook:  Loosing a veteran with 39 games played 19 of them as a starter is always a loss.  However, the future looks bright at the safety position as the Irish have a number of talented options ready to prove their abilities.

Justin Ferguson – Wide Receiver

Story:  Ferguson decided to transfer to Western Michigan.

Loss / Outlook:  Although it was for personal reasons and sighting that it had nothing to do with the school, the departure of Ferguson is more of a symbolic loss then a tangible one.  The Irish are still deep with potential at the receiver position.

Gunner Kiel – Quarterback

Story:  After redshirting his freshman year in South Bend and possibly concerned about sitting behind Golson for a couple of years, Kiel transferred to Cincinnati.  It’s been a winding road for a kid who committed to Indiana, then LSU before signing with Notre Dame and is now at Cincinnati.  All that, and he has never played a down of college football.

Loss / Outlook:  Prior to losing Golson for the season, it did not seem like a big loss, but now it is definitely amplified.  Depth at the Quarterback position has taken a hit, especially as he was seen as the #1 prospect coming out of high school.

Monday, July 15, 2013

It’s Rees deal with it.

There are many storylines and questions to be answered for the 2013 season.  There are players who over time may have bigger numbers and bigger impacts, but for the success of the Fighting Irish in 2013, there is no player more important than Tommy Rees.

I don’t see Rees having or even needing to have a Heisman-like season for the team’s overall success (although that would be a pleasure).  He does, however, need to control his mistakes and miscues.  As goes Rees, so go the Irish.

Any and all of the running backs can average 100 yards per game, but if we are turning the ball over in the red zone, that won’t matter.  Turnovers will not only negate Brian Kelly and Chuck Martin’s offensive weapon statistics, but will also give opposing offenses the opportunity to put up points.

Defensively, it has to become frustrating at some point to constantly be on the field bailing out the offense.   Fortunately, in football the defense can score points while pitching a shutout against opposing offenses.

Tommy is the leader on the field who can make his teammates look and be better.  Rees is also a favorite off the field and in the locker room.  The rest of the team will follow and play for Rees.  Of course, Tommy could pass for 4,000 yards, 20 Touchdowns and no interceptions, and the rest of his team will still need to play very well if Notre Dame hopes to get back to a BCS Bowl this season.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Ranking Notre Dame’s the top Commits from the High School Class of 2014

#5 Quenton Nelson – Ranked as the number seven OT in the nation he already has pluses in aggressiveness, arm length and size so at 6’5” 300+lbs as a junior, enough said.

#4 DeShone Kizer – After Malik Zaire he may be the only scholarship quarterback on Notre Dames roster in the fall of 2014.  He was also had a respectable showing at the Elite 11.  And where Zaire is supposed to be Golson 2.0, Kizer could be version 3.0.

#3 Jay Hayes – If for no other reason at 6’5”, 270lbs and growing he will have the chance to jump in sooner than later in a pivotal position left vacant by Nix.

#2 Jimmy Byrne – I know a lot of people don’t even think he’s the second best OL on this list but I like how well rounded his game is.

#1 Elijah Hood – He’s good, real good and should contribute to the Irish running game from day one.  A downhill runner who does not have the elusiveness to make defenders miss but his power makes them think about moving aside.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Why Malik Zaire must play in 2013.


The plan for true freshman and early enrollee Malik Zaire was to have him redshirt in 2013, learn the offense and get accustomed to big time college football life while senior Tommy Rees would play the backup role.  Zaire would play the role of back up in the 2014 season, maybe even pushing Golson a bit for the starting role.  Now, with Everett Golson stumbling academically, everything has changed. 

On the surface, the plan is go with Tommy Rees who has been named the starter while fellow senior (redshirt) Andrew Hendrix will be the backup so that Malik can save a year of eligibility.  However, things may be different if we look forward to the 2014 season.  First, we have to understand that there is no guarantee that Golson will make his way back to South Bend, and if he does, if he will be in the right physical or mental shape to resume his role as starting quarterback.  I think it is a 50/50 shot at best for Golson even coming back to the Notre Dame campus.  Tommy Rees will be gone, as he will have used up his four years of eligibility.  Andrew Hendrix will have a year of eligibility left, but if he has not worked his way into any quality playing time by now, it is unlikely that he will be of much assistance, and who knows if Kelly will want to use a scholarship spot on a fifth year backup quarterback. 

Zaire is the only quarterback coming in for 2013 and there are no current verbal commits at quarterback for the class of 2014.  So the best case scenario is that the Irish will have Hendrix - a fifth year senior who has not played meaningful snaps, Golson - who will have been away from the team for a season, and Zaire – a late freshman commit who may or may not have taken a game snap.   The worst case scenario - Golson does not come back and Hendrix does not return for a fifth year, leaving Zaire (who did not take a game snap because he was redshirted) and no incoming freshman quarterback with walk on Charlie Fiessinger as a backup.  Please note that Hendrix is a pre-med student and will be looking at Medical Schools for the fall of 2014.

I am not for playing freshmen unless they are absolutely necessary for the team.  This is definitely the exception to that rule.  Zaire is not needed for this season but he may be essential next season and needs to have some work in his portfolio.  Malik does not need to start, but it could be catastrophic if Notre Dame’s ONLY option in 2014 is a Redshirt Freshman with NO game experience.

Monday, June 10, 2013

It is what it is.

With Brian Kelly naming Tommy Rees as his starter for the Irish, everyone can move forward with their summer and focus on the fall without the constant speculation and questions surrounding a traditional quarterback controversy.

“We always move forward,” Kelly said. “I don’t live in the past, and I don’t spend too much time in the future. I live in the present, and in the present, we have Tommy Rees. We have Tommy Rees, who is an established player, and he will be our starter. We think Andrew Hendrix and Malik Zaire can contribute, but Tommy will be our starter.” – Brian Kelly at Grand Valley dinner in Grand Rapids

It would be nice for Rees to start against Temple in South Bend on August 21 and be 12-0 as a starter when the clock strikes zero at the end of the Stanford game in California on November 30 with no hiccups along the way, but that might be a bit much to ask.  Sure, there are concerns with Rees, especially compared to the lost incumbent – starting with speed, agility and athleticism (career long run of 12 yards and a long run of 2 yards last season) and the BIG one, turnovers (30 in his career, 24 interceptions and 6 fumbles).

On the flip side, there are a lot of programs that would love to have the experience of Tommy Rees running their offense heading into the 2013 season; appearing in a total of 33 games, 18 games as a starter (14-4), 34 passing touchdowns,  and a career passing completion of almost 58% for over 4,400 yards.

Another thing to keep in mind is that like every other player in the country, from season to season there is the excitement of the development in the off season.  Fans and coaches alike come to the first practice of the season looking to see what players have taken their game to the next level – whether they’re stronger, faster, or in the case of the quarterback - smarter and more accurate.   Maybe the most important for a quarterback from year to year is the understanding of the playbook, which is not an issue for Rees.  At the very least, fans should be excited that Rees has possibly improved and an improvement of a quarterback with a winning percentage of 82 a good thing.

The biggest thing Rees has working for him are his teammates.  The senior has the respect and loyalty of his fellow Irish players.   As far as his relationship with Coach Brian Kelly, most people see it as one of a lot of yelling and disappointment on Kelly’s side, but I see it as one of a player and coach who know each other and know what to expect from each other.

At the end of the day our choices are limited.  Option #1: Rees, who we are pretty familiar with - his good, bad and ugly as mentioned above.  Option #2: Andrew Hendrix, a 6’ 2” 220 lb. senior with limited game experience, appearing in a handful of games with no starts.  His stat line (even for a reserve) is minimal at best - 23 completions for 304 yards with 1 TD and 2 interceptions while rushing for 203 yards on 33 carries for an average of 6.2 yards per carry and one touchdown.  Option #3:  Malik Zaire, a true freshman who was an early enrollee and at 6’1” and 205 lbs. is more of a dual threat quarterback than Golson (as Golson is a scrambler and Zaire is a runner).  In my opinion, Zaire has had a solid spring and received high praise from the coaching staff while throwing the only TD pass in the Blue & Gold Scrimmage.

Note: 6’1” 185 lb. non-scholarship quarterback Charlie Fiessinger is also on the roster.

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Golson Statement

Okay, folks, here is Talking Irish’s official position on the Everett Golson situation.

Keep the big picture in perspective before calling for Golson’s head.  He’s a college kid and college kids do stupid things.  Should you be upset as a fan?  Sure, but we (Irish Fans) have been through worse.   In my opinion, there is no excuse for academic issues for a big time Division I athlete.  With all of the support these schools offer their student athletes, it amazes me that anyone cannot get through the course load, but it does happen.

Although he may be able to and want to return for 2014, it may be better for Golson to transfer.  No matter what happens in 2013, Zaire is the heir apparent to lead the Irish Offense and 2014 is a good place to start.  A year off for Golson is a year of learning and development for Zaire, a taller, bigger, maybe faster athlete.

We basically have two choices - one, start the Zaire reign in 2013 and take our chances; or two, start Rees let his experience lead the Irish in 2013.  I have the confidence in Rees to lead this team.  We cannot undo what has been done; we can only move forward.

Whether it is Rees or Zaire, we need to have faith in Brian Kelly and follow him loyally into battle.

 

Monday, May 6, 2013

A look at the latest Irish Commit

At 6’5” 290+ pounds, Four-Star recruit Quenton Nelson from Red Bank, New Jersey becomes the ninth commitment from the class of 2014 and looks to shore up Notre Dame’s offensive line for the future.  He has one year left of high school football to continue his growth at offensive tackle (left tackle).  Nelson had offers from the likes of Miami, Ohio State, Michigan State, Florida State, Oklahoma, Oregon, Stanford and National Champion Alabama.   With his 3.3 GPA, Nelson will join fellow 2014 offensive line recruits Jimmy Bryne and Sam Mustipher in getting ready to block for running back recruit Elijah Hood.  At a recent Rivals Camp Series stop in New Jersey presented by Under Armour, Quenton Nelson turned heads with his quick feet holding off defenders from coming in from the outside and with his improved strength stopping straight on rushes.  Although listed and has played tackle in high school, he could move into a guard position.  He also will probably redshirt his freshman year.

PLAYER NOTES

Quenton is also a U.S. Army All-American.

Recruited by Bob Diaco and Harry Heistand

ESPN - 4 star (#19 OT, #11 NJ), 80 Grade

Rivals - 4 star (#8 OT), #66 Overall (6.0 Grade)

Scout - 4 star (#8 OT), #82 Overall

247Sports - 4 star (#15 OT, #9 NJ), #233 Overall (90 Grade)

Video Highlights



ESPN Testing Results